NevermoreFTW
Theme Avg.
Plugin Avg.
ProBoards Highlight Search Terms
Seriously a great addition. Should be standard on all forums! No matter what your forum is or is about, if you have Search on your forum you should have this plugin.
ProBoards Zombies
Great Game, I like that you can play in just a single board on your forum if you want. Also those button images are pretty spiffy.